Bill Compton and Edward Cullen: Who Would Reign Supreme?

Bill Compton News

Bill Compton and Edward Cullen: Who Would Reign Supreme?

Ollie Chong aka AdoreBill Jun 2, 2009 71

FEARnet.com is posing a little healthy competition between True Blood‘s Bill Compton (Stephen Moyer) and Twilight’s Edward Cullen (Robert Pattinson). FEARnet.com looks at both vampires and asks the question which vampire would reign supreme based on their strength and weaknesses? FEARnet.com states the following regarding Bill Compton:

Bill is just slightly older than Edward so he’s a got bit more fighting experience under his belt. He also lives alone and while he was part of a coven in the past, those blood-sucking “buddies” are all but dead. While this makes him an independent fighter, it also means he has no one to back him up. He’s clearly got a ton of pent-up aggression, what with Sookie taking up with that dog, so he may be able to use that in his favor. Then again, his tendency to leap with his heart rather than his head might trip him up.

Now on the side of Edward Cullen FEARnet states:

He’s younger than Bill and that means that he’s stronger. (Editor’s note: I think FEARnet got this part wrong because the OLDER you are the STRONGER you are) But, he’s a vegetarian which in a one-on-one battle might be a detriment. (Think back, has he ever fought a blood-sucking vampire on his own? Others have always been nearby to help.) His strong bond with his vegetarian vampire family would certainly come in handy, as would his ability to read the thoughts of his attacker. Edward is also known to remain clear-headed in high-tension situations and that is always useful when facing a formidable foe. Remember how he sucked the venom from Bella? Would a blood-sucking vampire like Bill be able to exhibit that kind of restraint?

So FEARnet wants to go to their website and respond in their comment section “who you think would make it out of this undead battle still undead and who would be going home in a coffin for good” So click the link at the “SOURCE” below and let them know what you think.

SOURCE: FEARnet.com

(Photo crredit: HBO Inc.)

71 comments

~ Caitlin December 29, 2010 at 1:29 pm

Season 4 is supposed to start on June 12th. As of now, the first or second episode is entitled “You Smell like Dinner”. On this site it said that there might be a pie shop moving into town.

lemor davidovici December 29, 2010 at 3:04 am

hi does anyone know when the new episodes of true blood will come on HBO ?.

Lara December 28, 2010 at 3:18 pm

Editor – nope, in Twilight world, the YOUNGER you are the STRONGER you are.. Not sure if this is the same for True Blood..

lemor davidovici August 24, 2010 at 11:38 pm

bill compton would win because he has more of a mean streak than edward does bill would fight more hard & more wicked meaner to save lives.

Antonio el hombre lobo August 24, 2010 at 11:19 pm

Bill Compton would win..Thats quite clear to Me! I would like to say though in Edward’s defense,For a brief moment, That In the books Edward Cullen was more brooding,predatory…and had a definite dark side. He certainly did not appear as the “cuddly moody prince” that the first film and subsequent ones portrayed him as! There definitely was a more dangerous edge to the Bella-Edward Relationship in the books…Even Jacob Black was somewhat more aggresive in his pursuit of her!

Having said That Bill Compton WINS Hands Down No Contest!
Oh and By the way, Alcide and Cooter could kick the snot out of Jacob Black,Too!
Go TB!!

Ronald August 24, 2010 at 9:49 pm

The Edward lovers don’t love vampires, they love sparkling fairies. Bill would kick Edward’s butt any day (except during daylight, because he’d burn, not sparkle, just like a real vampire.)

Nia April 11, 2010 at 2:55 pm

It is really not fair to compare the two.

Bill appeals to the more sophisticated mature woman. Which is the way it should be.
Edward, his character, is meant for teenagers, because he really still is one himself although he was turned many years ago.

They are both fine characters and seem to love fiercely. They are not trying to cheat, steal, or betray anyone. They both found the loves of their immortal lives.

I wish them both long lives and happiness with their beloveds.

Bill is probably stronger because he his older. But Bill does not have the benefit of a family of supportive vampires to help him or back him up. Bill is alone and fighting his own battles.
He lost so much when he was turned. His maker was a monster and attempted (and for a while succeeded)into turning him into one.

For all that Bill has lost and suffered, he is an admirable character, yes he still has dark qualities, but he is trying to change. To be a better person. That in itself is noble and deserving of respect.

Edward was more fortunate than Bill. He was dying and would have died had not his father turned him. Then he had a family to help him and show him the way to a better lifestyle.

Edwarde showed restraint from draining and killing Bella, but he had to be reminded STRONGLY by his father.

Bill on the other hand has shown great restraint when necessary. Their first kiss, Bill is the one to back away when his fangs came out. He instead took Sookie home.

When they first made love, he waited for Sookie to acknowledge his fangs. Had Sookie ever said no or showed fear, Bill would acquiesce and not go any further. Her safety and wellbeing has always been paramount to him.

I will love and admiore Bill for all he was and all he has yet to be.

lemor davidovici April 11, 2010 at 2:35 pm

i like both vamps but i pick bill he will reign supreme !.

monalisa April 11, 2010 at 2:05 pm

i love both of them but i rather pick edward
CAUSE IM A BIG FAN OF HIM

mrs edward April 11, 2010 at 2:02 pm

edward is younger and more stronger and more sexy

edwardlover April 11, 2010 at 2:00 pm

i love edward
he is the one

saba April 11, 2010 at 1:59 pm

why u asking me the queation
i love and never hate edward cause he rocks

sara April 11, 2010 at 1:58 pm

its easy edward

samira April 11, 2010 at 1:57 pm

i luv both but ill pick edward cause he is fast and can easily kick anyones ass
he killed james who is a tracker in the first movie

fardowsa April 11, 2010 at 1:54 pm

edward obviously

Antonio March 29, 2010 at 1:54 pm

Perhaps Bill would win However Edward would be better at restraining himself and maintaining composure. Plus While Bill may be more savvy,Edward is wiser. Bill loses his temper and is given to fits of unbridled emotion In other words,Its difficult for Bill to keep a “cool head” especially in a crisis!
Recall how Bill “lost it” during that whole Jessica goes home to her parents thing? Self control and composure are Always important! Bill may be stronger and have more experience,But Edward has a higher EIQ Emotional Intelligence quotient Who would win in a battle? Probably Bill No Doubt! Who would win when it comes to Mental strength? Edward JMHO

Katra March 29, 2010 at 11:10 am

Bill wins this one EASILY! LOVE HIM!

Kristine March 29, 2010 at 8:46 am

i used to love Edward
after watching True Blood
i think im in love with Beelllll now

sota August 15, 2009 at 3:37 pm

bill’s a vamp and ed’s a douche, no competition whatsoever.

misha July 21, 2009 at 2:04 pm

i love bill, he is dammed hot dont matter he old. love him.

Nia July 19, 2009 at 12:15 pm

If it was Bill, who wouldn’t???

Rem July 19, 2009 at 10:19 am

i’d become a vap slut

Nia July 19, 2009 at 9:51 am

Bill, Bill, Bill, Gosh I love that vampire. Leave Edward to the tweens.

Linda July 19, 2009 at 6:10 am

Bill would of course their is no comp.

Daemon July 19, 2009 at 3:12 am

Bill is so goddamned hot! I love his face and his body. Love everything about him. Edward’s icky looking to me, deformed actually

sarah June 24, 2009 at 1:29 pm

same here! hes an awsome vampire! XD

Denise June 23, 2009 at 3:05 am

Ok Alisa, whatever, as you seem to know it all, perhaps before you reply to me again you should maybe go wash your mouth out with soap. Peace out!

Alisa June 23, 2009 at 1:12 am

Bitch i know you are just Edward Cullen trying to self-promote yo shit

Denise June 22, 2009 at 10:11 am

OMG Shannon, thank you! *bows down at your feet* You summed Eric up completely, finally someone that agrees with me.

Nia June 22, 2009 at 9:50 am

I love Bill, end of story.

shannon_momma June 22, 2009 at 8:44 am

I agree with you completely. Bill is a big pile of steaming.. you know what i mean. He betrayed Sookies trust big time, even if he really did start to care about her after the fact, he never spoke up until forced and all his macinations put sookie under the control of the vamp queen (where she doesnt want to be). Eric however, remained behind in dallas when the house was attacked and protected her while bill ran off, and that is only one example of how Eric puts her before himself. Eric respects sookie, doesnt lie, and openly admits any motives he may have. I love Eric. Bill is ok, but i doubt i could forgive him either.

Lori June 22, 2009 at 6:55 am

Who would even want them to fight!!?!??! Can’t we just squish them together & make one REALLY hot vamp???

Denise June 22, 2009 at 4:42 am

Alisa…You can have your own opinion but is there any need to be so crude! Everyone else has said how they feel without being vulgar, there is no need for that!

Linda June 21, 2009 at 11:26 pm

I agree. I think Bill is the best.Edeard is a boy. Bill is a real man in every way.Love looking at him any time.He could make reading a news paper look sexy.

Alisa June 21, 2009 at 8:10 pm

Bill would tear Edward up yo! Bill has experience and Edward is a limp dick motherfucka..

Linda June 21, 2009 at 1:13 am

Bill would win.Edward is a lover not a fighter.

SELENE June 20, 2009 at 8:25 pm

Denise completely agree with you on everything you said!, I vote for Edward Cullen because he is beautiful, honest, the sun does not hurt him, it is not allergic to silver, and is very strong and fast … Now if the competition was with Eric .. I’m sorry he had kicked his ass to Edward in every way …

Nickie June 20, 2009 at 11:20 am

I think Bill would win.

We are talking about the movie and tv shows…not the books.

Yes there are more things that can hurt Bill, which in my opinion only makes him a stronger fighter because he knows that he could be hurt. He is more aware of things and will make him fight harder to win it fast. Edward has less to worry about which would make him over confident.

And if Edward and the other vamps in Twilight have diamond hard skin….how can they be ripped apart so easily by each other?

And Bill knows that after he would win the fight, he could have amazing sex with Sookie and some fresh blood 🙂

But Edward doesn’t even have that to look forward to. And didn’t anyone ever think that its kind of wrong for a 100+ vampire to be with a teenager?

Nia June 19, 2009 at 2:47 pm

I really like your comment MaraAnn. You voiced everything I feel!

Nia June 19, 2009 at 11:40 am

Hi Denise,
I did not mean to offend you in any way. I am as passionate about the books (and the show) as you seem to be. I respect your opinion and will agree to disagree. That is the beauty of the written word, we can interpret it as we feel. I hope you enjoy the show as much as we have here in the states. We have just started season 2 and Alan Ball has not failed in his surprises for us. It is amazing. It may not be what you hope it will be in regards to Eric(at least not yet). As I have said before, I believe Eric will play a very big role in the show, as the seasons progress, and get in the middle of Bill and Sookie. I forsee much drama for them all. So please be patient and enjoy the show, and support it and Alan Ball. Hope to hear from you again.

Denise Strand June 18, 2009 at 3:45 pm

I do understand the books completely, I’ve read them all twice. And I called Bill an Asshole because in my eyes he is one, yes he was forced to do what he done, but he was also forced by Eric to tell the truth, if he hadn’t off been then sookie would never have known the truth. Yes by the end off book nine he does start to redeem himself, but through past experience off crapy men myself I don’t forgive lightly. Yes I probably shouldn’t let my own experience mix with fiction but I can’t help it. And in response to your comment below, I never said Eric was perfect, he is the opposite, but at least he is honest he never lied to sookie, not once. And when he lost his memory he never really returned to who he once was. I think Eric is misunderstood. And I can’t wait to see him come to life on screen. As I have said before I haven’t even seen the 1st series off true blood because I live in the UK, it doesn’t air here until 17th July, but I can’t wait to finally see what gets brought to the screen.

Nia June 17, 2009 at 8:12 am

Gosh AdoreBill, it is so good to hear form someone who makes sense about the books and the show. I agree with you on all counts when talking either about the books or the show. Reading comments written about Bill, that he was a jerk and Eric was so perfect (books) is rediculous. Those people are reading the books with their lust and not their heads. In regards to the show, I am just happy that Alan Ball has taken it and made it his own. I am loving it. For the Eric lovers out there, as I have said before, Eric will be playing a big role, so just be patient.

Nia June 17, 2009 at 8:05 am

I don’t understand how you can call Bill an Asshole? Did you truly read and understand the books? I don’t want to say much more but Bill was forced, and later came clean with all his heart and soul.
I see that you are an Eric lover and therefore have a thing against Bill. You must separate the books from the show and enjoy them both in their own way because they are the same and yet different. Be patient, I see Eric having a much bigger role in the show. He is a sexy and fun character. I love the surprises Alan Ball has given us with the show. I would never want it to be exactly the same as the books.

Junkie1 June 16, 2009 at 10:35 pm

Let us not forget that Edward can go out in the daytime. Boom done. Edward wins. However, I think they would be contemporaries at the very least.

We have a whole load of movie/tv Vampire-related goodness at our site if you’re interested: http://littlejunkies.wordpress.com/tag/vampires/

E. Wilson June 12, 2009 at 4:25 pm

Edward would (unfortunately) win. We have to defer to the respective “worlds” built around either character.

TRUE BLOOD’s vampires are subject to many of the traditional rules present in folklore — susceptibility to sunlight and silver, the need to sleep, and prohibitions against killing another vamp, for example. On the other hand, TWILIGHT’s vampires have next to no vulnerability (one reason why that franchise is so uninteresting to me). Sunlight has no effect on them. Their skin is diamond hard. They never sleep.

Edward would simply have to bind Bill with silver or fight him until dawn, when Bill’s power would be minimal. Then he could ‘kill Bill’ (no pun intended) however he chose.

YOYOYOYO PAY ATTENTION June 12, 2009 at 3:20 pm

I personally think Edward cullen will win..
think about it, his body is diamond strong so literally nothing will puncture or wound him..besides dismembering him
Bill is also strong and fast, but he does bleed and he can be wounded
Plus, EDWARD DOESNT burn in the sun like Bill does!

Edward is also not allergic to silver!!

there are many differences..but i think that there shouldnt b a poll about who would win in a fight. i think there should be a one about which one is hotter..what do you think?
I’d stil have 2 say edward XP

Heather June 10, 2009 at 5:38 pm

Fledgling by Octavia E. Butler is a great story and so is The Society of S by Susan Hubbard, it also has a sequel if you happen to enjoy it. Both are different from typical vampire books, which is why I love them. I also recommend the Anita Blake, Vampire Hunter series…. But those tend to be pretty sexually graphic and the later ones are more so than the ones in the beginning. I happen to like the series up to a point, but there are those that can’t stand them anymore.

andrea June 9, 2009 at 4:55 pm

psht, who needs that much info as to why …We all know BILL WOULD KICK HIS SCRAWNY ASS AHA!!!!!

Denise Strand June 5, 2009 at 1:38 pm

I’ve read books by Kresley Cole, the “Immortals after dark” series, I found them really good, they have quite graphic sexual content though so if your under 18 I would not recommend them. Also I loved the “Morganville” series by Rachel Caine, they are more teen books but I loved them, book 6 is just out and book 7 is due out in November. the Christine Feehan “Carpathian” series is also very good.

Rachelle June 5, 2009 at 10:06 am

Can anyone reccomend any good vampire books/series besides twilight or trueblood?

Rachelle June 5, 2009 at 10:04 am

Someone said that in the twilight saga younger Vampires are stronger so thats why Edward would win. Thats not true! In the saga only for the first year are they stronger because it takes that long for them to burn through all the blood their human bodies held.

Denise Strand June 5, 2009 at 3:22 am

Ok If you havent read the books then I would highly recommend them, both the Twilight Saga and the Sookie books, I would not judge both based on Twilight the movie because it sucked and strayed so far from the book that I was cringing. There was some things that were from the book, like the incident when Edward was rude to her, but there was so so much left out off that film that explains so much. I really cant comment on True Blood to the book because the series doesn’t air hear until the 17th July. But I loved Bill up until the big twist came in the story and I feel extremely sorry for Sookie. I don’t know how far they will stick to the books in the next few series either, but you’ll understand where I’m coming from if they do. As for comparing the two books, I can’t because they are too completely different stories, and I love the world that Stephenie Meyer created, and they all did Kill at some point in their lives only Carlise and Rosalie haven’t. And why would Killing animals be any worse that killing a human? It just a difference off opinion and I love both storys because its a tale off two completely different worlds.

sarah June 5, 2009 at 1:38 am

Oh one more thing. As a true vampire. Vampires are not suppost to have feelings of another person they must kill for a good reason unless it has to deal with true love they feel for another person of the human world, to me bill has both a heart of stone towards the bad and one part for love with Sookie. Edward really needs to toughen up though. To me whats the point in being a creature of the night and death if your not able to kill when you’re suppost to?!

sarah June 5, 2009 at 1:33 am

I seen the twilight but never read the books. I watch true blood and love it and might read the books later on down the road. Personaly with the knowledge I have of both stories is that in True Blood Bill is that vampire that doesn’t kill animals and doesn’t need them to drink blood from to survive, which no vampire to me should be doing. He drinks the blood from sookie when needed before getting into any type of perdicament. He is strong in a lot of situations and although he isn’t bad, hestays true to sookie even if it means going through danger for her or keeping safe if a law in the ”vampire world is broken”. he is fast, and burns up like an actual vampire and when he does he can go under ground to be healed again! Unlike Edward from Twilight. I think its really cheating to say oh theres this vampire that happens to be so strong and can fight other guys. He needed too many vampires to help him and plus he doesn’t even get damaged by the sun which to me seems unfair cause any ‘Real” vampire would have their weaknesses too and they can just be undead forever. He was also a bit rude toward Bella at the begining and vampires shouldn’t be like that unless is his mistress wants him to be rough :D. To me Bill is a real vampire in the world of the state of Louisiana and is of course attractive more than Edward, both by looks and vampireness.

Denise Strand June 4, 2009 at 11:23 am

I apologise, I haven’t seen the tv show yet as I’m in the UK and it doesn’t air here until the 17th July, from what I understood and have been told by a friend in the states it is based on the books, as to how close it stays to the books I do not know. But not just myself but a lot off people who have read the books love Eric also, and not so much Bill, yes in the last book he comes through for Sookie and does prove he loves her, but he still was forced into that love in the beginning. Its just difference off opinion as too how strongly a person feels towards a character. I really hope Bill can change my mind about him in the next book/s.

AdoreBill June 4, 2009 at 8:24 am

Hi Denise,

Please remember we are talking about True Blood the TV show and not the book and based up to this point in time Bill has shown his love for Sookie to the point he was willing to sacrifice his existence in order to save her as we saw in the final episode of season 1. Yes I have read ALL the books and to say that if people read the books they will fall in love with Eric is incorrect. Many still have a very strong connection with the Bill character after reading all the books as well.

Denise Strand June 4, 2009 at 4:51 am

There is a major difference between how the vampires are described in Sookie Stackhouse books and Twilight. In Twilight Edward describes thats if he tastes human blood then a frenzy begins and they are unable to stop, meaning they kill ever time, its incredibly hard from them to abstain from drinking human blood, but they also have there emotions still intact, which enables them to truly love. All Edwards wants to do is protect Bella. As a vampire he is incredibly fast, faster than his whole family, he rips Victoria into pieces without even so much as getting a scratch on himself all because he can read their thoughts and know their next move. But I have said before that these are two different stories and should never be compared too each other. I’m such a huge fan off both off them and would never compare them too each other, But I would love Edward to kick Bills butt for his treatment off Sookie.

Denise Strand June 4, 2009 at 4:42 am

Crap sorry I must control my urge to write or at least put *spoiler alert* before my comment, but yes Bill turns out to be an asshole, thats all I’ll say for now and why I will always choose Edward over Bill, but then I would always choose Eric over the lot off them, he is one sexy Viking, from the start he is honest, funny..I cant say anymore if you are only going onto book two but be prepared to fall in love with Eric! LOL

Heather June 3, 2009 at 3:36 pm

Have you ever read the Twilight series? If so, you would know that in Eclipse, Edward is said to be one of the best fighters along side Alice, because they both know what moves the person is going to do next.

Dorothy June 3, 2009 at 6:41 am

That’s true also. Edward’s not a KILLER when it comes down to it.

lemor davidovici June 2, 2009 at 10:50 pm

I THINK BILL WILL REIGN SUPREME BECAUSE BILL IS MUCH STRONGER, FASTER & IS A BETTER FIGHTER EDWARD IS STRONG BUT HE DOESN’T HAVE WHAT IT TAKES TO KILL WHEN THERE IS NO OTHER CHOICE BUT TO KILL SO HE CAN PROTECT HIMSELF & HIS FAMILY & FRIENDS BILL IS STARTING TO RELIZE HE MUST STAY WITH HIS VAMPIRE FAMILY SO HE CAN BE AN EQUAL TO THE HUMANS.

vampire belle June 2, 2009 at 10:15 pm

I love both vampires and believe they can hold their own in any situation,It boils down to north and south again I guess. lol, maybe a face off!

Dorothy June 2, 2009 at 4:38 pm

Bill is extremely fast too. And I think in a fight, there would be too much confusion and ado in the brain for Edward to be able to identify the person’s next move. I mean, it happens so fast, plus Edward can’t focus on being offensive and defensive….Face it, Bill is best 🙂

Dorothy June 2, 2009 at 4:36 pm

NOOOO!!! I don’t want to hear any more about the book! I like the show a hundred times better after reading book 1, so I don’t want to know what happens! Bill tricking Sookie…??!?!?! Too much info.

Dorothy June 2, 2009 at 4:35 pm

My god there is no question.
Bill Compton is THEE vampire. Edward is a sissy vampire. All sparkly and “vegetarian” and boyishly stupid. Bill is the best vampire by far. He would kick Edward’s a$$. He killed the Rattrays with one throw!

Heather June 2, 2009 at 2:03 pm

Even though I love both vampires, I would have to say Edward. And I’m not one of those “OMG! OMG! EDWARD!!” fan girls. Bill might be a little older and stronger than Edward, but Edward is supposed to be extreamly fast, faster than his whole family, including the one that made him. He’s quick and has the extra advantage of being able to read minds. He might not have the strength, but knowing every move the other person is going to make and being faster than the other, that would make him the winner in my opinion.

Kirrilee June 2, 2009 at 1:49 pm

Actually, technically, in the Twilight saga, the older you are the stronger. It’s only for the first year or so when you’re newly converted are you actually stronger, then after about a year your strength starts to wane.

Either way Bill would kick Edwards butt.

And Eric would kick the both of them to hell and back. ^_^

MaraAnn June 2, 2009 at 1:48 pm

I agree that Bill would dominate over Edward. Bill is waaaay more level headed and can control himself better than Edward. Bill is older, wiser, stronger, quicker, smarter and less likely to back down from a fight. Bill fights for good reason only and has war experience on his side. Plus, I just like Bill more as a character. He has more personality and is much more attractive lol

Denise Strand June 2, 2009 at 1:37 pm

I wouldnt compare the two because its two completely different stories…However Bill was out to trick Sookie from the start, Edward wasn’t it was true love and not forced love as Bills was. I love both the twilight saga and the true blood books, they are completely different and I could never chose. Now if you compared him to Eric I would pick him all the way!!!!

giigii June 2, 2009 at 12:41 pm

I think they said the younger a vampire is, the stronger they are coz that’s what they say in the Twilight saga.

Anyway, Bill would totallyyy win ! Love him <3 🙂

shannon_momma June 2, 2009 at 12:25 pm

Bill would totally dominate, no question. Reasons:
1. Bill is older, hence STRONGER, not the other way around, vamps aquire strength and talents with age.
2. He nests alone, but he is a subject of the queen of louisianna, therefore under the protection of Eric Northman and all of his subordinates. Eric is over 1000 years old, none of edwards ppl could hope to stand a chance! Eric can fly and could be at bills side with barley a moments notice.
3. Edward may be able to stand sunlight, but he cant walk around in it because he is so conspicuous. He would have to find bills hiding spots first. Bill has a blood bond with Sookie, who can pretty well take care of herself along with her shape shifter and were friends, who should be revealed soon.
4. Bill does think with his heart when it comes to sookie, but he is level headed and cool in other situations.
5. Bill has more restraint than Edward in blood situations, as he frequently feeds on sookie during intimate situations without causing half the harm that Edward did trying to stop drinking. Bill can stop feeding, plus he doesnt need as much blood as the younger Edward.
6. It took most of Edwards ppl to stop one vamp, in a one on one fight he would lose big time! And if facing off group against group, my money would be on Bill, Eric, Pam, Chow, and the host of other vamps that owe Eric fealty, the shapeshifters from hot shot, and the were pack of shreveport, and sookies fairly grandfather (the prince) who would all be behind Bill.
7. Edward feeds on inferior animal blood, while bill gets frequent feeding from a human. Better blood, more strength.
Sorry edward fans, he would lose.

Related Story